Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu & Prices
National Average · 425+ Locations
70Menu Items
$9.45Avg Price
16Veg Options
6Combos
UpdatedToday
About Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu
Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a Chicago-born fast-casual sandwich chain with over 425 US locations, celebrated for its toasted sandwiches served on house-baked bread with live in-store music creating a warm, neighbourhood-cafe atmosphere. Founded as an antique shop on Chicago's North Shore in 1977, Potbelly began selling sandwiches and eventually became one of America's most beloved sandwich chains. Menu prices range from $1.49 for a cookie to $11.99 for a Big Italian sandwich, with most sandwiches priced between $7.99 and $9.99. The Potbelly Perks app rewards members with free sandwiches, birthday rewards, and exclusive member pricing on meal combos.
CuisineAmerican Fast Casual Sandwiches
Avg Menu Price$9.45
Calorie Range110 – 1060 kcal
Most ExpensiveBig Sandwich (Italian) — $11.99
Cheapest ItemRegular Cookie — $1.49
Total Categories9
Highlights
Best ValueOriginal Sandwich (Regular) — $7.99
TrendingTurkey Sandwich (Regular) — $8.49
Healthy PickChicken Salad on Multigrain (Regular) — $8.99
🏆 Best Value Ranking
1
Chicken Noodle Soup (Cup)
190 kcal · Chicken,Egg Noodles,Carrots,Celery,Broth
$4.62price
2
Original Sandwich (Regular)
560 kcal · Turkey,Swiss,Lettuce,Tomato,Onion,Mayo,Toasted Roll
$8.13price
3
Turkey Sandwich (Regular)
540 kcal · Turkey,Provolone,Lettuce,Tomato,Onion,Mayo,Toasted Roll
$8.45price
4
Farmhouse Salad
330 kcal · Mixed Greens,Turkey,Bacon,Cheddar,Tomato,Croutons,Ranch
$9.09price
5
Chicken Salad Sandwich (Regular)
560 kcal · Chicken Salad,Lettuce,Tomato,Toasted Roll
$9.20price
Full Menu
Category
Price
Calories
Popularity
🥗
Open Calculator →
Track calories for your Potbelly Sandwich Shop meal
Build your order and see macros, protein, and daily goals
💰 Cheapest Meals Under Budget
Chicken Noodle Soup (Cup)
$4.62
Popular
💰
Find Cheapest →
Want the absolute best value at Potbelly Sandwich Shop? Our tool finds it by budget automatically.
🍔
PB and J Sandwich (Kids)
$5.05
420 kcal
Peanut Butter,Jelly,Toasted Roll
Mushroom Melt Sandwich (Regular)
$8.68
Vegetarian Tomato Soup (Cup)
$4.55
Vegetarian Tomato Soup (Bowl)
$6.53
Vegetarian Broccoli Cheddar Soup (Cup)
$4.59
Vegetarian Power Grain Salad
$9.63
Vegetarian Chips (Regular)
$2.05
VegetarianVegan Mac and Cheese (Side)
$4.04
Vegetarian Apple (Side)
$1.55
VegetarianVegan Hand-Spun Shake (Regular)
$5.58
Vegetarian Hand-Spun Shake (Large)
$6.57
Vegetarian Regular Cookie
$1.53
Vegetarian Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.51
Vegetarian Brownie
$2.49
Vegetarian Fountain Drink (Regular)
$2.58
VegetarianVegan Hot Coffee
$2.53
VegetarianVegan Lemonade (Regular)
$3.04
VegetarianVegan These items aren't on the official menu but can be ordered by asking the right way.
Secret
The Potbelly Insider (Off-Menu)
Turkey,Meatball,Swiss,Provolone,Pepperoncini,Lettuce,Tomato,Oil,Toasted Roll
Price: $10.59 · How to order: Gluten,Dairy,Soy
Secret
Grilled Cheese (Off-Menu)
Swiss,Cheddar,Provolone,Toasted Roll
Price: $5.62 · How to order: Gluten,Dairy
Nutrition Intelligence
1
Big A Wreck Sandwich
$12.80 · 1110 kcal
60.0g protein
$0.21 per gram
2
Big Turkey Sandwich
$11.16 · 810 kcal
51.0g protein
$0.22 per gram
3
Big Italian Sandwich
$12.35 · 1020 kcal
51.0g protein
$0.24 per gram
4
The Potbelly Insider (Off-Menu)
$10.59 · 780 kcal
44.0g protein
$0.24 per gram
5
A Wreck Sandwich (Regular)
$9.53 · 740 kcal
40.0g protein
$0.24 per gram
⚖️
Compare Now →
Is Potbelly Sandwich Shop the best value for money?
Compare side-by-side with up to 4 other restaurants — prices, calories, and more
Menu Categories
Sandwiches
26 itemsSoups
8 itemsSalads
6 itemsShakes
6 itemsBakery
8 itemsSides
6 itemsBeverages
8 itemsCombo Meals
6 itemsCatering
4 itemsHistorical Price Trends
📈 Price Change History Per Item
Hand-Spun Shake (Regular)Now: $5.49
$4.792021
$4.992022
$5.192023
$5.492025
Italian Sandwich (Regular)Now: $8.99
$7.792021
$8.192022
$8.492023
$8.992025
Meatball Sandwich (Regular)Now: $9.49
$7.992021
$8.492022
$8.992023
$9.492025
Regular CookieNow: $1.49
$1.092021
$1.192022
$1.292023
$1.492025
Tomato Soup (Bowl)Now: $6.49
$5.292021
$5.592022
$5.992023
$6.492025
Turkey Sandwich (Regular)Now: $8.49
$7.292021
$7.692022
$7.992023
$8.492025
Items that were once on the menu but have since been removed.
Wanna Be a Chicken Sandwich
Was: $9.04
Discontinued
Smoky Chipotle Chicken Sandwich
Was: $9.23
Discontinued
Banana Bread
Was: $2.53
Discontinued
Price Reviews
4.3
0 reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to review!
